Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Coal Jaba's avatar

Doomy's article is a subject that makes my heart thump.

I agree with every sentence. When people think of liberties they often think exclusively of political liberties like speech, association, religion, and so forth. These are very important. However, what are these worth without economic liberty? Wickard v Filburn made certain that the federal government could regulate- in others words ban- all economic activity. In addition to being a major suppression of liberty it's also an end run around the Takings Clause. Think back to Obama's pledge to destroy the coal industry and then following through on that threat. Billions of dollars of property were ruined when he shuttered power plants and coal mines. Tens of thousands of jobs were lost. Much of the big mining equipment lost the bulk of its value and was sold for parts or exported for pennies on the dollar. Such is the fruit of Wickard v Filburn and its allied cases.

But it's not just SCOTUS that got it wrong. After all, it was Congress who passed the law and the President who signed it. No future Congress repealed it. Our nation has been teaching its youth that this is a legitimate power of the federal government, that economic liberties are, like the 2nd amendment, second class liberties. Even if SCOTUS overturns Wickard we still have to contend with what's in the hearts of Americans with regard to economic liberty. Will they elect legislators who support passing such a law again?

So much work needs to be done to instruct the nation on our full heritage of liberty, including the right to work in any trade you wish without government destroying your career. You don't have to be in the coal industry to fear that possibility. During Covid the Constitution became an artifact for a time and many were told they were "non-essential" workers. Here's to hope that SCOTUS can strike a blow and that friends of economic liberty to persuade their fellow Americans that those liberties are as important as the ones in the Bill of Rights.

Expand full comment
Andy Fately's avatar

Envisioning how this would change things in DC, I can see a future where the federal government becomes a shadow of its former self. if there is any time when this could happen, it seems this administration is the best chance we have. Here's hoping!!!

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts